We have already had occasion to speak of the importance of symbolic form in the transmission of doctrinal teachings of a traditional order. Let us return to this subject to add some complementary clarifications and show even more explicitly the various points of view from which it can be considered. First of all, symbolism seems especially suited to the needs of human nature, which is not purely intellectual but needs a sensory basis in order to rise toward higher spheres. We must take the human composite as it is, one and multiple at the same time in its real complexity; all too often, there is a tendency to forget this, ever since Descartes claimed to establish a radical and absolute separation between soul and body. For a pure intelligence, certainly, no external form or expression is needed to understand the truth, nor even to communicate to other pure intelligences what it has understood, insofar as it can be communicated; but this is not so for human beings. Ultimately, every expression, every formulation, whatever it may be, is a symbol of the thought it conveys outwardly; in this sense, language itself is nothing but a symbolism. There should therefore be no opposition between the use of words and that of figurative symbols; these two modes of expression would rather complement one another (and, indeed, they can be combined, since writing is originally ideographic and in certain cases, as in China, has always retained this character). In general, the form of language is analytical, “discursive,” like the human reason of which it is the proper instrument and whose course it follows or reproduces as accurately as possible; by contrast, symbolism properly so called is essentially synthetic, and for that very reason “intuitive” in a way, which makes it better suited than language to serve as a basis for “intellectual intuition,” which is above reason and must be carefully distinguished from the inferior intuition invoked by various contemporary philosophers. Consequently, if one is not content merely to note a difference and wishes to speak of superiority, then, whatever some may claim, it must be attributed to synthetic symbolism, which opens up truly limitless possibilities of conception, whereas language, characterized by more definite and fixed meanings, always places more or less strict limits on understanding. So let no one say that symbolic form is good only for the common people; rather, the opposite would be true—or, better still, it is equally good for everyone, since it helps each person understand the truth it represents more or less fully and more or less deeply, according to the extent of their intellectual capacities. Thus, the highest truths, which could in no way be communicated or transmitted by any other means, become communicable to a certain extent when they are, so to speak, embodied in symbols that will doubtless conceal them from many, but will reveal them in all their splendor to the eyes of those who know how to see.
Should we say that the use of symbolism is a necessity? Here a distinction must be made: in itself and absolutely, no external form is necessary; all are equally contingent and accidental in relation to what they express or represent. Thus, according to the teachings of the Hindus, any figure, for example a statue symbolizing this or that aspect of Divinity, should be considered only as a “support,” a point of focus for meditation; it is therefore a mere “aid,” and nothing more. A Vedic text offers an analogy that perfectly illustrates the role of symbols and external forms in general: they are like the horse that enables a man to make a journey more quickly and with far less effort than if he had to do it by his own means. Certainly, if this man had no horses at his disposal, he might still reach his destination, but with how much greater difficulty! If he can use a horse, he would be quite wrong to refuse on the pretext that it is more dignified not to resort to any help; and is that not exactly how the detractors of symbolism act? Moreover, if the journey is long and arduous, although it is never absolutely impossible to make it on foot, there may nevertheless be a real practical impossibility of completing it. So it is with rites and symbols: they are not necessary in the sense of absolute necessity, but are necessary in a certain sense, as a matter of propriety, given the conditions of human nature. But it is not enough to consider symbolism from the human side, as we have done so far; to grasp its full scope, we should also examine it from the divine side, if one may put it that way. Once it is established that symbolism is grounded in the very nature of beings and things, that it is in perfect conformity with the laws of this nature, and once we reflect that the laws of nature are, in essence, nothing but an expression and, as it were, an externalization of the divine Will, does all this not authorize us to assert that symbolism is of “non-human” origin, as the Hindus say, or, in other words, that its principle reaches further back and higher than humanity?
It is no wonder that, in connection with symbolism, the opening words of the Gospel of Saint John have been invoked: “In the beginning was the Word.” The Word, the Logos, is at once Thought and Speech: in itself, it is the divine Intellect, which is the “place of possibles”; in relation to us, it manifests and expresses itself through Creation, in which some of those same possibles, which as essences have been contained in Him for all eternity, are realized in actual existence. Creation is the work of the Word; it is also, and precisely for that reason, His manifestation, His outward affirmation; and this is why the world is like a divine language for those who know how to understand it: Caeli narrant gloriam Dei (Psalms, 19:1). The philosopher Berkeley was therefore not wrong when he said that the world is “the language that the infinite Spirit speaks to finite spirits”; but he was wrong to believe that this language is merely a set of arbitrary signs, whereas in reality nothing is arbitrary, not even in human language, since every signification must originally be grounded in some natural affinity or harmony between the sign and the thing signified. Precisely because Adam had received from God knowledge of the nature of all living beings, he was able to name them (Genesis, 2:19-20); and all ancient traditions agree in teaching that the true name of a being is one and the same thing as its nature or its very essence. If the Word is Thought inwardly and Speech outwardly, and if the world is the effect of the divine Word uttered at the beginning of time, nature itself may be taken as a symbol of supernatural reality. Everything that exists, in whatever mode, having its principle in the divine Intellect, translates or represents this principle according to its own manner and order of existence; and thus, from one order to another, all things are linked and correspond to one another, contributing to universal and total harmony, which is like a reflection of divine Unity itself. This correspondence is the true foundation of symbolism, and it is for this reason that the laws of a lower realm can always be taken to symbolize the realities of a higher order, where they find their profound rationale, which is at once their principle and their end. We take this opportunity to point out the error of modern “naturalistic” interpretations of ancient traditional doctrines, interpretations that simply reverse the hierarchy of relations between the different orders of reality: for example, symbols or myths have never had the task of representing the movement of the stars; rather, the truth is that they often contain figures inspired by it and intended to express, by analogy, something altogether different, since the laws of that movement physically translate the metaphysical principles on which they depend. Lower can symbolize higher, but the reverse is impossible; moreover, if the symbol were not closer to the sensible order than what it represents, how could it fulfill the function for which it is intended? In nature, the sensible can symbolize the supersensible; the entire natural order can, in turn, be a symbol of the divine order; and, moreover, if we consider man more particularly, is it not legitimate to say that he himself is a symbol by virtue of being «created in the image of God» (Genesis, i, 26-27)?
Let us add that nature acquires its full meaning only when we consider that it provides a means of rising to knowledge of divine truths, which is precisely also the essential task we have recognized in symbolism. These considerations could be developed almost indefinitely; but we prefer to leave it to each person to do so through an effort of personal reflection, since nothing could be more beneficial; like the symbols that are their subject, these notes should only be a starting point for meditation. Words, moreover, can convey only very imperfectly what we are discussing; nevertheless, there is another aspect of the question, and one no less important, which we will try to make understood, or at least intuited, by giving a brief indication. The divine Word expresses itself in Creation, we said, and this is comparable, analogically and with due proportion, to thought expressing itself in forms (there is no longer any reason to distinguish between language and symbols properly so called) that veil and reveal it at the same time. The primordial Revelation, the work of the Word just as Creation is, is embodied, so to speak, in the symbols handed down from age to age since the origins of humanity; and this process is once again analogous, in its own order, to that of Creation itself. Moreover, is it not possible to see in this symbolic embodiment of the 'non-human' tradition a kind of anticipatory image, a 'prefiguration' of the Incarnation of the Word? And does this not also allow us to perceive, to some extent, the mysterious relationship between Creation and the Incarnation that crowns it? We will conclude with one final observation concerning the importance of the universal symbol of the Heart and, more particularly, the form it takes in the Christian tradition, that of the Sacred Heart. If symbolism is in its essence strictly in accordance with the 'divine plan', and if the Sacred Heart is the center of being, both really and symbolically, then this symbol of the Heart, in itself or through its equivalents, must occupy a truly central place in all doctrines derived more or less directly from the primordial tradition. |
||||||||
| Renè Guenon | ||||||||